EWC Logo

Select your language

EWC / CGA

Fitness to practise banner
Fitness to practise case studies
Fitness to practise case studies

The following case studies provide clear, practical insights into the expectations and standards expected of you in both your professional practice and personal life.

Based on real examples, they illustrate common challenges and pitfalls that can lead to a fitness to practise hearing. By highlighting these scenarios, we aim to offer valuable learning points to help you uphold the highest standards in your profession and safeguard your registration.

Inappropriate physical contact with a learner

In this case study, we look at an example of where a registrant was suspended following a proven case of unacceptable professional conduct in relation to their inappropriate physical contact with a learner.

Summary of the case

The EWC received a referral from an employer following the dismissal of a registered member of staff. The registrant was dismissed because it came to light they had had inappropriate physical contact with a learner.

During this hearing, the Fitness to Practise Committee was asked to consider whether the following allegations were proven, that the registrant:

  1. took hold of a pupil’s wrist or arm:

a. when it was not reasonable or necessary to do so in the circumstances; and
b. used more force than was reasonable in the circumstances.

The registrant attended the hearing, and was represented. The registrant denied the allegations.

The Committee’s findings

The Committee (supported by an independent legal adviser throughout) considered the evidence provided to it and whether the public would find that the allegations amounted to unacceptable professional conduct.

The Committee considered that an unreasonable and unnecessary taking hold of the arm and/or wrist of a learner, with more force than was necessary in the circumstances, amounted to conduct which fell short of the standard expected of a registered person.

As a professional, the registrant had a responsibility for the health and wellbeing of the learners they worked with, and was seen as a role model to them.

The Committee determined that the registrant’s conduct was likely to impact on the trust and confidence that the public places in registered professionals.

Having carefully considered all of the circumstances of this case, the Committee concluded that a Suspension Order (without conditions) was sufficient to address the public interest concerns.

This was a serious instance of unacceptable professional conduct where a lesser sanction was not sufficient. However, the Committee concluded that the conduct found proven was not fundamentally incompatible with being a registered person when the wider context was fully considered.

Code of Professional Conduct and Practice

In this case, the individual was in breach of several principles from the Code, including that registrants:

Personal and Professional Responsibility

1.1          recognise their personal responsibility as a role model and public figure, to uphold public trust and confidence in the education professions, both in and out of the workplace.

1.2          conduct relationships with learners and young people professionally by:

  • communicating with learners and young people respectfully, in a way which is appropriate for them
  • ensuing any physical contact is necessary, reasonable, and proportionate

1.4          have a duty of care for the safety, physical, social, moral, and educational wellbeing of learners and young people:

  • acting on anything which might put a learner, or a young person’s, safety or welfare at risk
  • reporting, in line with 5.3, any safeguarding issue, or any other issue, which may potentially harm a learner, or young person’s, safety or welfare.

Professional Integrity

2.1          are accountable for their conduct and professional competence

Professional Knowledge and Understanding

5.3          know, understand, and comply with the current safeguarding policies, procedures, and guidelines which are relevant to their practice.

Lessons learnt

Physical contact with learners and young people is sometimes necessary and proportionate in education and training settings. It can also be encouraging and positive when used appropriately.

However, it is important that you ensure you behave acceptably and professionally in all situations.

We strongly encourage you to be familiar with the relevant national, mandatory guidance, as well as targeted local guidance and policies such as codes of conduct, safeguarding, behaviour/discipline and health and safety.

If something does go wrong, early intervention can be invaluable. Seek advice and support at the earliest possible stage from your line manager, trade union or at the very least, someone you trust.

Further reading and guidance

Good practice guide: Appropriate physical contact with learners and young people